writings

If I knew every language, I could read every book in its original form without losing anything in translation, which is an art itself, & reading the same work in different languages is fascinating.


I so badly wish I could understand everything in its intended voice. The idea of losing even a bit of nuance to translation no matter how much I learn leaves me quite disheartened. What is missing extends beyond the words themselves, but to the culture behind them: the exact place and time, its history, what it meant to grow up there; things that cannot always be carried across languages in full. Nuance is not only lost, instead it can also unintentionally distort the author's words. Consequently, fluency does not eliminate distance.


Vladimir Nabokov's relationship with translation interests me as it approaches this feeling. He appears to deeply distrust any translation that attempted to adapt the prose, arguing that this weakens the original text. This approach to translation is heavily polarizing, immortalized through his translation of Eugene Onegin. On the opposite end of the spectrum we have Jorge Luis Borges, who viewed translation as co-authorship, something that paves way for literary evolution... something that may possibly surpass the original. 


Despite my stubborn, voracious desire to understand every facet of an author's voice and erase the distance created by nuance, I've come to learn that translation is an art in itself. There are so many meticulously, elegantly translated pieces of work with so much effort and care put into them, unlike anything the world has ever seen beforeAlongside these modern translations, learning another language through English, the lingua franca of the 21st century, provides an incalculable number of resources.


I've found myself very thankful to have learned and retained a workable amount of French over the years, and I'm happy to have gotten back into something which has been a part of my life for so long. Watching movies in French surprises me with how much I understand, and I was unaware of how beautiful the music is! Very embarrassed with how much fun I'm having with it when I hated so vehemently on the language as I absolutely despised studying it in schoolThough to be fair the verb conjugation is fucking stupid.


I wish to further my studies in German as well; such a strange contrast to what French teaches you, being more akin to a puzzle than to the reliance on patterns and familiarity. I love Grimm's Fairy Tales, and we own copies in both English and German, but the original German edition is rife with archaic vocabulary and grammatical structures. Modernized, shortened editions make adapting a lot easier. I want to reach the point where I can read the original, keeping a glossary of modern words and their archaic equivalents.


Anyway... none of this changes the fact that I'll never have enough time to read every book I want to read, and of course, reading multiple translations of one book is quite the task. The audacity of myself lamenting not being able to read books in languages I'll never learn when I haven't even read every English book ever...

Comments

vrelle

Website
so real,, a year or two ago when i was super fixated on dostoevsky novels, i started noticing how varied of a read a different translator can make. i tried learning russain for a bit, but eventually neglected it.. regularly consuming media of another language does make it easier, that's probably why i couldn't get a grasp of russain unlike french (thanks etre etre and notre dame de paris.. - -" i wonder if there's a ich bin version?)

linear

Website
well put! i'm inclined to agree with borges, but it does take a very skilled translator (and writer) to make a text come alive. even if we can't learn everything there is to know, it's still good motivation to seek out more perspectives, i think. wishing you luck in your german studies :)

Bobby

Website
It’s interesting.. I never once thought about writings and their original stories or meanings before you first brought this up to me about 2 months ago.. And I did find myself studying more about what I’ve missed in books I’ve read before, I learned the stranger sounds completely different and much more serious in original French than the cool cynical voice I read as a teenager.. who knows what else I have missed.